Rails 3 RC Routing: resource member routes lack defaults

I can't reproduce this, can you provide more info, try doing a test case or upload an application?.
Thanks.

I think the problem is the guide shows the example using a string, whereas it should really be a symbol. I can't reproduce the missing action error but it is correct that the route isn't named.

The action is added here, however I leaning towards thinking that it should removed and require the action to be specified. The problem with adding the action and name by default when specifying a custom action as a string is that you can add extra parameters in the path so you should really be adding all the options. e.g:

resources :photos do
  get 'preview/:size', :on => :member
end

It wouldn't add too much overhead to add a regexp check on the name to see if it's compatible with adding it by default I guess, but the guide definitely needs updating.

I should be sleepy when i watched to this but i agree with Andrew, also +1 for the patch.
Just wait for José resolution :).

(from [7a7012c7177fd9811305c03b1db0ec0d5008f19e]) Fix a bug where symbols and strings were not behaving the same in the router. [#5431 Rails 3 RC Routing: resource member routes lack defaults state:resolved] http://github.com/rails/rails/commit/7a7012c7177fd9811305c03b1db0ec...

[bulk edit]