Routes problem

I have the same problem.

The rake routes command shows a correct definition:

clubs GET /clubs/:id/(.:format) {:action=>"show", :controller=>"clubs"}

This call will result in a "No action responded to the-club-to-view"-error:

http://localhost/clubs/the-club-...

This call works:

http://localhost/clubs/show/the-...

Greets Rocco

In addition to this problem .. nested routes do not work either:

map.resource :cms do |sub|

sub.resources :categories

end

calling /cms/categories in the browser results again in a "No action responded to categories"

Greets Rocco

Is there any chance that you have the desert plugin installed?

no, i have not installed the desert plugin.

I can reproduce the problem on Mac Os X 10.5.6 with a fresh rails 2.3.0 application by doing:

Create a new app with one resource

rails testapp ... cd testapp script/generate controller clubs (adding map.resources :clubs to routes.rb) rake routes

*Correctly outputs the generated resources:*

clubs GET /clubs(.:format) {:action=>"index", :controller=>"clubs"}

      POST   /clubs(.:format)                   {:action=>"create", :controller=>"clubs"}

new_club GET /clubs/new(.:format) {:action=>"new", :controller=>"clubs"} edit_club GET /clubs/:id/edit(.:format) {:action=>"edit", :controller=>"clubs"}

 club GET    /clubs/:id(.:format)               {:action=>"show", :controller=>"clubs"}
      PUT    /clubs/:id(.:format)               {:action=>"update", :controller=>"clubs"}
      DELETE /clubs/:id(.:format)               {:action=>"destroy", :controller=>"clubs"}
             /:controller/:action/:id           
             /:controller/:action/:id(.:format) 

Let's test the route in the Console

./script/console Loading development environment (Rails 2.3.0) >> rs = ActionController::Routing::Routes ... >> rs.recognize_path('/clubs') => {:action=>"index", :controller=>"clubs"} <- Okay! >> rs.recognize_path('/clubs/1') => {:action=>"1", :controller=>"clubs"} <- NOT okay! action should be "show" and i miss the :id => 1

Hope this helps.

Greets -act

Sorry, the Formatting is quiete bad in the last post (preview option would be great here :) )

Anyways, when generating a new rails app with 2.3.0, generating a controller and adding it's resource in routes.rb and then trying to validate the route in the console, i get the same wrong result (/clubs/1 routes to :controller => clubs with :action => 1 instead of :controller => clubs, :action => 'show' and :id => 1

greets -act

And a final note .. the recognition in the console works when invoking the command with an additional method-option:

rs.recognize_path('/clubs/1', :method => :get) => {:action=>"show", :controller=>"clubs", :id=>"1"}

rs.recognize_path('/clubs/1') => {:action=>"1", :controller=>"clubs"}

I thought that :get is magically called when ommitting.

greets -act

okay, forget all my last three postings. i basically just proved that indeed the routing works with a fresh rails 2.3.0 installation. Doesnt solve my problem with my updated application but i guess you can close the ticket after all, since it seems to be an individual applcation problem on my side.

final greet :) -act

actraiser,

I just saw this ticket. On 2/16, I made changes to smurf to fix something identified by cainlevy. I'm also using smurf with Rails 2.3.1 right now without any problems. If you would like to, please get the latest smurf and try again. Let me know if there are any more problems.

• gus (aka a thumble monk)